A cautionary tale re my liking for Scarlet Tigers

Followers of the Oxon Wildlife blog may recall I have a colony of Scarlet Tiger moths in my wildlife garden at King’s Copse Park, Garsington that I am more than a little partial to. 2014 was a bumper year for them, with a huge crop of spring larvae being succeeded by literally dozens of adult insects in their flight season. It quite amused me to see the neighbours shutting their windows as these little beauties became most active in the early evenings.

Scarlet Tiger

Scarlet Tiger on Brunnera

I know very little about moths, and until now have only guessed at my Scarlet Tigers’ life cycle. In past years I have noticed small larvae on the exterior walls of my park home more or less throughout the winter months. In spring much fatter ones mature on the food plants of Comfrey (Symphytum caucasicum) and Brunnera that I cultivated as shade-tolerant ground cover before the trees and hedgerow behind my unit were cleared by the landowner in 2013.

Well something has devastated those original food plants during 2014’s dry late summer, and that malaise has spread to most ground cover plants in my garden through early autumn. “Surely there can’t be so many slugs and snails active in such dry weather, and are they eating the moth eggs?” I wondered. But neither did I notice tell-tale munching caterpillars. Just recently I’ve been finding part-grown Scarlet Tiger larvae on my exterior walls again.

On arriving home this evening I saw that one of my prized pot Abutillon’s had succumbed to the above-noted malaise. And there they were: a crop of part-grown Scarlet Tiger larvae going about their chomping business. Whilst being pleased to see them, I was a little disappointed at their choice of alternative food plant. It was too late for this particular Abutillon in its present season. A  scan around the faded autumn garden revealed many more munchers on perennial Geranium, Lady’s Mantle (Alchemilla mollis), Geum rivale, Pulmonaria, Centaurea, Tellima, Hollyhock, and the variegated Brunnera that had survived the initial onslaught. Yike! –  though this could save me some work cutting down those various perennials at season’s end.

Chomped Brunnera macrophylla

Chomped Brunnera macrophylla

Cue a web search that turned up an article on the Amateur Entomologists’ Society site. From this it is worth noting that (1) Scarlet Tiger larvae do indeed over-winter but with up to 80 per cent losses; and (2) there have been 43 recorded food plants. I am beginning to fear for my garden in the 2015 season. If there are any moth experts out there who can enlighten me further as to just what I’m letting myself in for, I’ll be pleased to learn more.


2 thoughts on “A cautionary tale re my liking for Scarlet Tigers

  1. Hi Peter, we have Scarlet Tigers in our garden as well though they seem to feed exclusively on the weed Green Alkanet of which we have far too much! I didn’t know that they were so catholic in their choice of foodstuff – we’d better make sure not to eradicate all the Alkanet.


    • That’s probably wise. In 2013 I was careful to maintain an area of the invasive Brunnera to cater for the moths, hence this year’s large numbers. But with the early demise of that top growth the larvae have turned to plants that I wouldn’t want them to feed on next spring. Hopefully by the time those that survive the winter become active again there will be plenty of new Brunnera and Comfrey growth for them to concentrate on.
      NB. Having checked my flower books I see that what I’m calling Brunnera is indeed Green Alkanet, whilst the related Brunnera macrophylla is the variegated form that I grow.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s